I found myself strangely free of responsibilities for a brief time last weekend. In a burst of spontaneity, I broke my self-imposed “read-the-book-first” rule and took myself to see The Hate U Give. A classmate from high school had challenged friends on social media to see it, process, think, listen. I have a lot of respect for her, so I did.
Well, I’m stuck on process.
Every time I start to try and even talk myself through my response, I just stop. I tried to write about it, which led to the title of this post. So I decided to just tell you a story. It requires me to share a bit more about myself than I normally do. It’s hard for me to hit publish on a post like this, because the sad truth about writing is that you do not control the reader nor the reception. But I’m going out on a ledge.
Some time ago, Austin had just enacted the ban on handheld devices in the city. I knew this was the case; I did not know that included using your phone for GPS unless it was physically mounted somewhere (i.e, propped on your dash counted as handheld, whether you had a hand on it or not). While on my way to photograph a building for a client, I was pulled over on Mopac Expressway by a police officer on a motorcycle.
For those of you who are not from Austin, Mopac is a much-travelled highway west of downtown, by which the wealthier parts of town are accessed. People drive extremely fast, there is virtually no shoulder in many places, and there is significant space between exits. So, when the officer signaled for me to pull over immediately with no exit in sight, I did my best to get as far over on the (non-existent) shoulder as possible. It is important to note that I had NO idea why I was being pulled over. I wasn’t speeding. I wasn’t texting. I wasn’t calling anyone. I couldn’t imagine it was something like a taillight, or surely the officer would follow me to an exit for safety.
The officer came to the passenger side and indicated for me to roll down the window, which I did. The conversation went something like this:
Officer: “Do you know why I pulled you over?”
Me: “No, sir, I do not.”
Officer: “Austin is a handsfree city and you were using your handheld device.”
Me: “No, sir, I was not holding my phone. It is running navigation for me.”
Officer: “We will discuss this in a moment. For now, please hand me your license and proof of insurance.”
PAUSE. At this point, I have to share something I have kept fairly private, until now. When I first began photographing real estate properties, I sometimes found myself alone in remote and vacant homes. I had some safety measures in place, including calling my partner when I arrived and when I left, or sometimes taking her or my husband along. I had the frightening experience of walking in on a squatter once. Even more often, I would arrive at a property to find myself alone with a male homeowner, and a few times my inner radar sounded the alarm. In response, I would call my husband on my cell phone…or pretend to if he didn’t answer. Now, inside I consider myself quite intimidating and fierce, but the reality is, I’m a pretty small woman. I’ve taken self-defense in the past but I am smart enough to know there are limits to my abilities. So, after a few such instances in a relatively short span of time, I decided to get my concealed handgun license. I took the course, legally purchased a gun, and began to carry it with me on these shoots. Because I am a responsible, licensed gun owner, I know that when pulled over, you are supposed to hand over your CHL with your license and inform the officer if you have a gun in the car, and where it is. So…
Me: [handing my license, CHL, and insurance card] “Here is my license and my concealed carry permit. I do have a gun in the car. It is in my camera bag in the back seat.”
Officer: [stiffens a bit, and takes a more authoritative tone] “Ma’am, I’m going to need you to exit the vehicle. Do not make any extra movement; just step out of the car now.”
Me: [looking out my window at cars whizzing by at 80mph about two feet from my door] “Sir, I can’t step out of the car! That’s oncoming traffic…I’ll be killed! I can tell you exactly where the gun is, and you can remove it while I keep my hands on the wheel.”
Officer: [a bit sterner] “Ma’am, that will not work. You have to get out of the car while your weapon is there. You may not make any move except to step out of the car.”
Me: [still not okay with dying on Mopac, so I straighten my back and respond, respectful but firm] “Sir, we are not pulled over in a safe place for me to exit this car from the driver’s side. YOU won’t even come around to the driver’s side. I can direct you to my weapon, or you can watch me climb over the passenger seat to get out, but I am NOT stepping into the right lane of Mopac!”
Officer: [really stern] “Ma’am…” [stare]
Me: [staring back] “Sir…”
Officer: [continues to stare at me; I stare back with excellent posture] “Fine. You say the gun is in the backseat? You can climb out on this side. Do not reach toward the back seat while doing so.”
So out I clambered, in a skirt and heels. He gave me a ticket and a lecture, and I stood as tall as possible and took it, knowing the entire time that I would be showing up to that court date (which I did, and won). When all was said and done, I drove off, furious. He was willing for me to endanger my life (Austin people can back me up – this is not hyperbole) over phone navigation, despite the fact that I clearly respect the law and genuinely sought not to be perceived as a threat (as evidenced by my handing over my CHL and identifying my gun and its location without waiting to be instructed).
As I later relayed the story to my husband, I was angry. I could easily have lied about there being a gun in the car, and I guarantee the officer would have believed me. I was polite, and respectful, and disagreed without being aggressive or combative, and yet he was going to insist that I step out onto Mopac. How would he feel if it were his wife being asked to do the same, I fumed. I am generally a huge fan of police officers, but I was NOT a fan of this one.
Shortly after this event occurred, a friend posted on Facebook about a talk she had with her teenage sons. I did not know then to call it “the talk” because that was vernacular that never entered my parenting world, unless you were referring to the birds and the bees. No, I mean “the talk” about her black sons driving, and what to do if they were pulled over for any reason (or, for no reason they were aware of, as I was on Mopac that day). Where to put their hands. If they were wearing a hoodie (like the ones their baseball and football teams wore for warmups), make sure the hood was down. The voice to use. The words to use. The best way to show respect, to obey, to comply. Basically – everything they should do to avoid violence, or worse. Even if they knew they had done nothing wrong.
I remember telling my husband about it, in the light of my own recent interaction at a traffic stop. The truth is, I knew I was on the side of right in my situation. There was no reason for that officer to be concerned about violence from me, because I followed the letter of the law and simply didn’t want to endanger myself due to the choice he made about where we would stop. So I felt confident and justified in standing up for my own safety at that traffic stop. But reading my friend’s words, I realized that, were I to trade places with her son and all other circumstances were equal, no one in the world would advise me to take that same confident and justified stance. No one.
And I just don’t know what to do with that. Still.